Choosing Between Large Format Tiles and Subway Tiles for Your Shower Walls

Designing your shower can be both exciting and overwhelming. One of the most crucial choices you will make is the type of tile to use. Large format tiles and subway tiles are two of the most popular options available. Each offers distinct characteristics, benefits, and style. In this guide, you will discover the pros and cons of each tile type, allowing you to make a decision that perfectly suits your taste and requirements.

Understanding Large Format Tiles

Large format tiles, generally 12x24 inches or larger, have gained popularity for their modern aesthetic and minimal grout lines. For example, a shower featuring large tiles can have as few as five grout lines compared to standard tiling, which might exceed twenty lines in the same space. This significantly reduces visual clutter.

One key advantage of large format tiles is their ability to create a more open and seamless look. Fewer grout lines can make a small shower feel larger and more spacious, enhancing the overall experience. Moreover, cleaning is more straightforward due to fewer joints where soap scum and grime can build up.

However, installation can be trickier. Large format tiles require a skilled professional who can ensure that they are laid flat, as small imperfections in the wall can become quite noticeable. In fact, improper installation can lead to tiles cracking or shifting, translating to additional costs for repairs.

Exploring Subway Tiles

Subway tiles, typically measuring 3x6 inches, have a classic, versatile design that works well with various aesthetics—from rustic to modern. They can be arranged in multiple patterns like herringbone, brick, or a checkerboard, providing ample opportunities for creativity. For instance, arranging subway tiles in a herringbone pattern can add a unique touch to your shower, making it stand out.

Cost is another significant factor. On average, subway tiles range from $1 to $5 per tile, making them a more budget-friendly choice compared to large format options, which can cost anywhere from $5 up to $20 or more per tile, depending on the material and brand. If you are on a tight budget, subway tiles might be the economical solution you need.

One downside to subway tiles is the increased number of grout lines, which can make them require more maintenance. Studies show that homeowners with subway tiles may spend up to 50% more time on cleaning due to the numerous grout joints compared to large format options.

Aesthetic Considerations

When contemplating tile choices, consider the ambiance you want to create in your shower space.

Large format tiles deliver a contemporary and sleek look, ideal for modern bathrooms. They allow for bold statements when used in contrasting colors or textures. For example, pairing a matte black large tile with glossy white fixtures can create a striking focal point.

In contrast, subway tiles evoke a sense of warmth and nostalgia. Their classic design works harmoniously in both traditional and eclectic settings, creating a cozy atmosphere. If you desire a shower that feels inviting and timeless, subway tiles are undoubtedly a great choice.

Practical Considerations

Consider practical aspects before making your decision.

Large format tiles can help visually expand a small shower. If you have a limited space, choosing these tiles can work wonders in opening up the area. On the other hand, if you are looking to save money or enjoy a DIY project, subway tiles might be your best bet due to their affordability and comparatively easier installation.

Maintenance is another key factor. If low upkeep is a priority, large format tiles could be the better option thanks to fewer grout lines that trap dirt and soap residue. Homeowners often report spending less than half the time cleaning large tile installations versus traditional subway tiles.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between large format and subway tiles for your shower walls ultimately comes down to your taste, budgetary constraints, and practical preferences. Both tile options have unique advantages that can enhance your bathroom's look and functionality.

Taking time to consider your style and maintenance needs is crucial before deciding. With the right tile choice, your shower can evolve into a beautiful, enjoyable space that serves you well for years ahead.

A modern shower featuring large format tiles on the walls.